Deciding whether to lease or buy a car is easier when both choices are measured over the same period. This worksheet shows how to compare upfront costs, monthly payments, fees, mileage, maintenance, depreciation, equity, and end-of-term choices so you can test the decision against your actual driving habits and ownership timeline.
Overview
A lease is generally a contract to use a vehicle for a defined term and mileage allowance. Buying means financing or paying for the vehicle and building ownership equity over time. Neither option is automatically cheaper for every driver. The better fit depends on how long you plan to keep the car, how many miles you drive, how much cash you can put down, and whether you want to return, replace, or keep the vehicle at the end of the agreement.
The most useful comparison is not simply the lease payment versus the loan payment. Compare the total cost of using the vehicle during the same period. For example, a 36-month lease should be compared with the cost of buying and owning the same vehicle for 36 months, including the vehicle's estimated value at the end of that period. If you plan to keep a purchased car for eight years, compare it with the cost of leasing vehicles for the same eight years, including likely replacement leases. That second calculation requires more assumptions and should be labeled as an estimate.
Before comparing offers, establish the out-the-door price. Review taxes, registration, dealer fees, add-ons, and financing terms separately rather than relying on an advertised monthly payment. The out-the-door offer worksheet can help organize those figures.
How to estimate
Step 1: Choose the comparison period
Use the period that matches your real plan: the lease term, the expected time before selling a purchased vehicle, or the number of years you expect to keep the car. A shorter ownership period makes resale value and selling costs especially important. A longer period gives buying more time to spread acquisition costs, but it also requires realistic estimates for repairs, maintenance, insurance, and depreciation.
Step 2: Calculate the lease total
A practical lease estimate is:
Lease cost = amount due at signing + total scheduled payments + acquisition fee + disposition fee + expected mileage charges + non-covered maintenance or repairs + early termination cost, if applicable - refundable deposit or credit.
Confirm whether the amount due at signing includes the first payment, registration, taxes, a security deposit, or a capitalized cost reduction. Treating a large down payment as a cost at signing is important: if the vehicle is stolen or totaled early, that money may not be recovered in the same way as a refundable deposit or unused credit.
For mileage, compare your expected total miles with the contracted allowance. If you expect to exceed it, include the stated per-mile charge in the worksheet. Do not assume you can avoid the charge by returning the vehicle early; check the contract. Also include the disposition fee if it applies when the vehicle is returned, and check whether it is waived when you lease or buy another vehicle from the same provider. A waiver should be included only if you are confident that condition will apply.
Step 3: Calculate the purchase total
For a financed purchase, estimate:
Purchase cost = down payment + total loan payments made during the comparison period + taxes and fees paid separately + interest and finance charges + maintenance and repairs + selling or trade-in costs - estimated vehicle value at the end.
If loan payments are already used in the calculation, do not add interest a second time. Total loan payments include both principal and interest. If you sell the car before the loan is paid off, calculate the expected sale price minus the remaining loan balance. That amount is your equity and is the value to subtract from the cost. If the balance is higher than the vehicle's sale value, the result is negative equity and should be treated as an additional cost.
An ownership budget worksheet can help separate the car payment from insurance, fuel, parking, and other ongoing costs. Include those expenses in both scenarios only when they differ. For example, fuel may change if the lease and purchase candidates have different powertrains, while routine insurance costs may be similar but not identical.
Inputs and assumptions
Record the following inputs from written lease and purchase offers. Use the same vehicle configuration where possible; a different trim, mileage allowance, or incentive can make the comparison misleading.
- Vehicle price: Record the negotiated selling price, not just the manufacturer's suggested price or a monthly-payment advertisement.
- Lease terms: Enter term length, annual mileage allowance, amount due at signing, monthly payment, acquisition fee, disposition fee, security deposit, mileage rate, residual value, and purchase-option price.
- Purchase terms: Enter down payment, trade-in credit, loan amount, APR, term, monthly payment, taxes, registration, dealer fees, and any prepaid products.
- End value: Estimate the purchased vehicle's sale or trade-in value at the end of the comparison period. A trade-in estimate is not guaranteed, so test a low, middle, and high case. Researching your trade-in car value can provide a starting point.
- Use: Enter miles driven per year, expected wear, commuting conditions, towing or cargo needs, and whether you can stay within a lease's mileage limit.
- Operating costs: Estimate insurance, routine maintenance, tires, repairs, registration renewals, and any warranty coverage. A lease may remain under a manufacturer's warranty during the term, but warranty limits and maintenance responsibilities vary by vehicle and contract.
- Taxes and incentives: Apply local taxes, registration rules, rebates, loyalty offers, and finance or lease incentives exactly as stated in the offer. These items can change by location and model year.
Money factor and APR are different measures. A lease quote may show a money factor rather than an interest rate, while a purchase quote usually shows APR. Use the figures from the actual offer and ask the dealer or lender to explain any unfamiliar term. Do not convert one into the other unless you understand the lender's calculation and have checked the result against the quoted payment.
Also account for wear-and-use standards on a lease. Excess damage, missing equipment, unusual tire wear, or modifications may create charges at return. A purchased vehicle does not have a contractual wear bill at resale, but poor condition can reduce its market value.
Worked examples
The following illustration uses hypothetical figures solely to show the method. Replace every number with the terms in your own offers.
Example A: Three-year comparison
Assume a driver compares a 36-month lease with a purchase of the same vehicle and expects to drive 12,000 miles per year. The lease has $3,000 due at signing, 36 monthly payments of $425, a $700 acquisition fee, a $400 disposition fee, and no expected mileage charge. Estimated lease cost is:
$3,000 + ($425 × 36) + $700 + $400 = $19,400.
Assume the purchase requires a $5,000 down payment, followed by 36 payments of $610. At month 36, the vehicle is expected to be worth $21,000, and the remaining loan balance is estimated at $14,000. Equity is therefore $7,000. If maintenance and repair costs during the period are estimated at $2,100, the purchase cost is:
$5,000 + ($610 × 36) + $2,100 - $7,000 = $22,060.
Under these assumptions, the lease costs less over the first 36 months, but the result is not a universal conclusion. Change the end value, loan rate, negotiated price, mileage, or lease incentive and the outcome can change. The buyer also retains an asset with equity, while the lessee has no vehicle equity at return. That difference matters if the buyer keeps the car beyond the comparison period.
Example B: High-mileage driver
Suppose another driver expects 20,000 miles per year but is considering a lease with a 12,000-mile annual allowance. The expected excess is 24,000 miles over 36 months. If the contract's excess-mile rate is 25 cents per mile, the estimated mileage charge is $6,000. Add that charge to the lease total before comparing it with buying. The driver should also request a higher-mileage lease quote; a higher payment may still cost less than the contract's excess-mile charge.
Example C: Lease with a purchase option
A lease purchase option can be evaluated separately. Add the total lease cost through the purchase date to the stated purchase-option price, plus any purchase fee, taxes, registration, and new financing costs. Then compare that amount with the expected market value and with the cost of buying the vehicle from the beginning. The purchase option is not automatically a bargain merely because the vehicle is familiar; inspect its condition and compare its price with similar used cars for sale.
When to recalculate
Revisit the worksheet whenever a material input changes. Recalculate after receiving a revised dealer quote, changing the down payment, switching loan terms, changing annual mileage, or choosing a different trim or model year. Recheck it when interest rates, manufacturer lease programs, incentives, residual values, insurance premiums, taxes, registration costs, or expected resale values change.
At the dealership, request a written itemization of the amount due at signing, monthly payment, total lease obligation, mileage allowance, end-of-term charges, purchase-option price, and every added product. For a purchase, request the selling price, APR, term, amount financed, total finance charge, and estimated payoff balance. Compare offers using the same term and the same cash assumptions.
Finally, test three cases: a favorable case, a realistic case, and a cautious case. Increase the expected mileage, lower the resale value, and add a maintenance reserve in the cautious case. If the same choice remains affordable across all three, it is more resilient. If the result changes easily, prioritize flexibility and keep more cash available for insurance, repairs, registration, and other ownership costs. Reuse this worksheet whenever your driving pattern, budget, or vehicle options change.